Navigating the complexities of a lemon vehicle can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to understanding what counts as a 'reasonable number of repair attempts' under Texas Lemon Law. For consumers caught in this frustrating scenario, this blog post offers clarity and guidance. We delve into the nuances of what 'reasonable' really means in the context of repeated repairs, arming you with knowledge to assert your rights effectively.

Understanding 'Reasonable Number of Repair Attempts’

In the realm of Texas Lemon Law, determining a 'reasonable number' of repair attempts is a pivotal factor in validating a lemon claim. The law offers some guidelines, but the interpretation can be complex and depends on various factors.

Defining 'Reasonable'

The term 'reasonable' varies case by case. Generally, four unsuccessful repair attempts for the same issue within the first 24 months or 24,000 miles might be considered reasonable. For severe safety defects, even two attempts can suffice. However, this is not a hard and fast rule and can depend heavily on the specifics of each case.

Factors Influencing 'Reasonableness'

Several aspects influence what is deemed reasonable. The severity of the defect is critical – a severe safety issue might require fewer attempts compared to a less critical problem. The total time the vehicle is unusable due to repairs also plays a crucial role in this assessment.

Documenting Repair Attempts

Proper documentation of each repair attempt is essential in building a strong lemon law claim. 

1. Keep All Repair Orders and Receipts

  • Every Visit Counts: Obtain a copy of the repair order every time you take your vehicle in for service, not just for major repairs.
  • Details Matter: Ensure that each repair order includes the date of service, mileage, description of the problem as reported, and the repairs attempted or made.

2. Maintain a Detailed Repair Log

  • Record Dates and Descriptions: Keep a personal log noting every time the vehicle exhibits the problem. Include dates, times, and specific details about the issue.
  • Environment and Conditions: Note the driving conditions and any other relevant environmental factors when the problem occurred.

3. Communicate in Writing

  • Written Correspondence: When possible, communicate with the dealership and manufacturer in writing. Use emails or letters for formal complaints or to reiterate issues discussed in person.
  • Document Phone Calls: If you discuss the issue over the phone, follow up with an email summarizing the conversation, including dates and names of the representatives you spoke with.

4. Collect and Organize Supporting Evidence

  • Photographic/Videographic Evidence: If the problem is visible or audible (like a strange noise or a malfunctioning part), take photos or videos as evidence.
  • Expert Opinions: If possible, get an independent mechanic's opinion or inspection report especially if the dealership is unresponsive or disputes the issue.

5. Be Consistent and Clear in Describing the Issue

  • Use Same Descriptions: Each time you bring up the issue, describe it consistently. Using different terms might give an impression of unrelated problems.
  • Be Specific: Avoid vague descriptions. Clearly articulate the problem and how it affects your use of the vehicle.

6. Understand the Warranty Coverage

  • Know Your Warranty: Be clear on what your warranty covers. This can help in discussions with the service department and in ensuring that all relevant issues are addressed under the warranty.

7. Be Persistent but Polite

  • Stay Professional: Always maintain a professional demeanor in all interactions, even if you’re frustrated. This helps keep the focus on resolving the issue.
  • Follow Up: If you feel your concerns are not being addressed, don’t hesitate to follow up. Persistence is key in these cases.

8. Know Your Rights

  • Educate Yourself: Understand the basics of the Texas Lemon Law and other consumer protection laws. Knowing your rights can empower you in discussions and negotiations.

9. Consider Seeking Legal Advice

  • Legal Consultation: If you’re unsure about your situation or if the dealership continues to be unresponsive, consider consulting with a lawyer who specializes in Lemon Law cases.


Dealing with a lemon vehicle is undoubtedly challenging, but understanding the intricacies of what constitutes a 'reasonable number of repair attempts' can significantly strengthen your position. Armed with the right knowledge and documentation, you can navigate the legal landscape more confidently and effectively assert your rights under Texas Lemon Law.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

You May Also Like

When Lemon Law Meets New Tech: Handling Claims for Autonomous Vehicles

As autonomous and semi-autonomous vehicles increasingly roll onto roads, the interplay between advanced automotive technologies and existing legal frameworks becomes critically important.

April 24, 2024

Navigating Software Glitches in Electric Vehicles: A Lemon Law Perspective

The dawn of electric vehicles (EVs) has reshaped the automotive landscape, propelling us toward a future where our roads are dominated by software-driven cars.

March 25, 2024

Understanding the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and Lemon Law

In today's consumer-driven society, understanding one's rights under various warranty laws is not just practical but necessary. The Federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act is a beacon of protection for anyone navigating the complexities of warranties, especially in lemon vehicles.

March 22, 2024